Blog Book Club #63: Our Infernal Neighbors

Welcome to the blog book club. We’ve reached 2015. We’re reading “Our Infernal Neighbors” by John Laviolette. While the content was originally on the blog The Nine and Thirty Kingdoms, it was later removed and PDF compilation can be accessed in the first post of this thread.

Next week we’ll be talking about an important player role in dungeon crawling. It’s On Callers by Daniel Collins of Delta’s D&D Hotspot.


This compilation document is longer compared to what we usually read for the blog book club, clocking in at 39 pages. The central conceit here is that D&D should have devils and demons and their ilk, but there doesn’t have to be a cumbersome 9 fold alignment or dozens of planes to make this possible. So here many of these nasty creatures live deep in the earth and can pass through the solid rock with the abilities to make their bodies ethereal. Similarly, the magical abilities of these creatures are stripped down to what’s most essential. There’s still quite a bit of structure here to the supernatural hierarchy with ranks of supernatural creatures that grow more powerful.

Here’s what’s in this document:

Chapters

  1. Our Infernal Neighbors - an overview of the concept, monster design, notes on alignment

  2. Infernal Forms - tools for deciding how these creatures look

  3. Demonic Infernals - chaotic destructive monsters

  4. Diabolic Infernals - lawful jailers that corrupt and punish humans

  5. Demonoidal Infernals - supernatural monsters that have some demonlike traits but aren’t demons? Not really sure what they are going for with this one

  6. Hags and Infernal Beasts - tall monster women that enter dreams through the astral plane and also things like hellhounds

  7. The Fae - otherworldly members of isolated courts with alien minds.

  8. Saturnians - psychic toad monsters from outer space

Appendix A - contains an ease of use reference for statblocks

Appendix B - License and notes.

Overall, I think I agree with the central thrust of all this. Player characters shouldn’t have to leave their current existence to encounter the famous supernatural beings you expect to be in D&D. In later editions, I grew frustrated that fantastical monsters were gated away to remote planes. This made the players world feel decided less fantastical. The lore doesn’t need to be complex unless that’s what the people playing the game enjoy. Ultimately, even the system proposed here goes further than I need it to. Give me a grab bag of recognizable devils and demons, the tools I need to create my own bespoke monsters, and a single otherworld these things can be summoned from and banished back to and I’m good.

If planar drama was the central focus of a campaign like Planescape or Troika, I could see myself wanting to delve further into the mysteries and motivations of such creatures, but I’m largely content for their natures and plots to be inscrutable to PCs beyond what they are doing within a particular adventure locale. What do you think?

Since we’ve stumbled on the perfect time of year for this topic, I leave it with a Happy Halloween!

2 Likes

Hmmm. He seems to have spent deal of time creating a set of rules that’s as extensive as the one he rejects. I find much of what he wrote to be too limiting, much the same as with the RAW approach.

I’ve always just used the RAW surrounding demons and devils and such to be a loose organization that may or may not apply in every corner of my multiverse. I use demons or devils with any constraints given in the written materials, instead expecting them to fit in my setting in the way I want them to. And I never worry about how well it matches up with RAW.

I suspect there are a great many tables where the RAW materials are only loosely adhered to. I’ve not played with any edition beyond 2ed, so I’ve no idea what was done to infernal beings in later editions. I just know that all of the critters presented for the editions I’ve played have been subject to my needs and the official info simply suggested usage.

1 Like