Blog book club: Let's start one

@yochaigal the list of blog posts I’m following has this disclaimer at the top:

some of these bloggers (especially early on) have shown themselves to be hurtful people, at least insofar as they are vocally sexist, racist, homophobic, and/or transphobic. I have included blog posts by these individuals to provide an accurate view of the play style’s historical development, but I disavow any harmful or destructive views expressed elsewhere by those individuals, speaking as a queer woman and a communist. So, you know. Caveat emptor

I know who some of those people are but clearly not all, given our interaction over on the latest post.

Can you suggest a way I can proceed with this project without causing problems for the RPG cauldron?

I’m not a fan of public lists. They only lead to problems. My suggestion is to just move on when someone points out a particular author is bad. It isn’t a big deal, I just assume everyone knows.

If I were that blogger I simply wouldn’t include them.

1 Like

So would you suggest we stop the current discussion about Melan diagrams and move on to the next blog post? I would like to keep taking about dungeon design if possible.

That seems prudent. Thank you!

The problem I have is that I wasn’t involved with the OSR blogosphere then and I have no idea who among the bloggers turned out to be problematic. I’d greatly appreciate it if somebody would clue me in, as I’d rather not spend time or money on people I can’t in good conscience support.

Next blog post from the original list? Wouldn’t that bring us into the same wheelhouse?

You can DM me here or on discord if you like.
No public lists please! It only causes more flamewars that don’t actually help anyone.

2 Likes

I think you can substitute the Alexandrians’ Jaquaysing the Dungeon (or whatever bullshit he decided to call it now) posts for the discussion of Melan’s diagrams without any loss of content.

2 Likes

See here for the post index.

4 Likes

Following up on these starting with #6 makes for a nice little backlog. Thanks for putting these together, Martin! :smiley:

1 Like

See here for the post index.

4 Likes

I will keep this list of blog club posts up to date as the weeks pass. Yochai has kindly given me forum permissions to keep editing this post beyond the usual deadline.

  1. Blog book club #1: On Thief Skills in Classic D&D
  2. Blog book club #2: Same description, same rule
  3. Blog book club #3.2: Xandering the Dungeon
  4. Blog book club #4: How to awesome-up your players
  5. Blog book club #5: Philotomy’s OD&D Musings
  6. Blog book club #6: Grand Experiments: West Marches
  7. Blog book club #7: Carlo’s code
  8. Blog book club #8: On the Oracular Power of Dice
  9. Blog book club #9: How Dragonlance Ruined Everything
  10. Blog book club #10: Shields Shall be Splintered!
  11. Blog book club #11: Three Clue Rule
  12. Blog book club #12: The Death of the Wandering Monster
  13. Blog book club #13: Playing with Death and Dismemberment
  14. Blog book club #14: Quick Primer for Old School Gaming
  15. Blog book club #15: Gygaxian Naturalism
  16. Blog book club #16: Gygax double feature
  17. Blog book club #17: Party like it’s 999